Moms Talk Murder
Welcome to Moms Talk Murder, the true crime podcast that takes you deep into the mysteries and chilling tales of unsolved cases, notorious criminals, and the forgotten stories that haunt our history. Each episode, we unravel the intricate details of real-life crimes, exploring the motivations behind them and the impact they have on victims and society. From infamous serial killers to gripping unsolved mysteries, join us as we delve into the darker side of humanity, examining evidence, interviews, and expert insights. If you’re captivated by the truth behind the headlines, tune in and journey into the shadows with us.
Episodes

Wednesday Feb 19, 2025
Wednesday Feb 19, 2025
In this special edition of Moms Talk Murder, hosts Chelsie and Michelle take the lead as they delve into the chilling world of execution methods throughout history. From medieval torture techniques like the brazen bull and Spanish donkey to modern-day execution methods such as lethal injection and the electric chair, the episode uncovers the gruesome details and historical significance behind each method. The discussion highlights the transition from ancient to contemporary practices, reflecting on the ethical implications and the evolution of the death penalty over time. Join us for a fascinating yet unsettling journey through some of the most notorious and disturbing execution techniques ever used.

Wednesday Feb 12, 2025
Wednesday Feb 12, 2025
Join Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie in this engaging episode of Mom's Talk Murder as they revisit the story of Ted Bundy by examining the film "Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil, and Vile" starring Zac Efron. After discussing the chilling details of Bundy's crimes, they share their candid reactions to the movie's portrayal of this infamous serial killer.
The hosts dive into the nuances of the film, analyzing Efron's performance and the cinematic representation of Bundy's complex relationships and trial, while offering personal insights and humorous interjections. From debating the accuracy of courtroom scenes to examining the depiction of Bundy's charisma, Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie provide a thorough review that is both insightful and entertaining.

Tuesday Feb 04, 2025
Tuesday Feb 04, 2025
Join Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie in the chilling continuation of their exploration into the life and crimes of Ted Bundy. In this episode of Mom's Talk Murder, the hosts dive into Bundy's arrest, his cunning escapes, and the series of gruesome crimes that shocked the nation.
Discover the story of Bundy's first arrest, the evidence found in his apartment, and his shocking escape from a courthouse library. Follow along as they unravel Bundy’s time evading capture, his audacious moves across the country, and his infamous attacks at the Chi Omega sorority house.
The trio also examines Bundy’s trials, the testimonies against him, and his unsettling ability to represent himself. Learn about his manipulative charm that captivated many, including his eventual wife, even as he faced numerous charges.
Experience the horror and fascination as Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie recount the tale of one of America's most infamous serial killers, leaving listeners with a deeper understanding of the monster behind the façade.

Wednesday Jan 29, 2025
Wednesday Jan 29, 2025
This riveting episode delves into the chilling and complex life of notorious serial killer Ted Bundy. Hosts Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie navigate through Bundy's early life, discussing his troubled upbringing and the manipulative charm he wielded over his victims. As they explore his heinous crimes, they shed light on his reign of terror across multiple states, revealing the disturbing modus operandi behind his attacks.
The episode also confronts the societal perceptions of the 1970s, highlighting the challenges faced by the victims and the authorities in piecing together Bundy's network of evil. The hosts discuss his notorious courtroom behavior and the paradoxical infatuation some had with his persona during the trial period.
Join the conversation with 'Mom's Talk Murder' as Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie dissect one of history's most terrifying figures, while also sharing personal anecdotes and insights into the dark psychology of Ted Bundy.

Wednesday Jan 22, 2025
Wednesday Jan 22, 2025
Join Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie on their intriguing journey back to Mansfield Prison, providing an updated and clearer discussion on its haunting history. As Ohio's top haunted house, Mansfield Prison, also known as Ohio State Reformatory, draws us into its dark past filled with eerie tales and paranormal activities.
In this episode, the hosts unravel the prison's architectural beauty, its historical significance, and the ghostly legends that reside within its walls. Discover why Ohio stands out not only for its haunted houses but also its infamous correlation with serial killers.
Embark on this thrilling exploration as the team shares spooky anecdotes, movie trivia about films shot at the infamous location, and delve into spine-chilling ghostly encounters.

Wednesday Jan 15, 2025
Wednesday Jan 15, 2025
In this gripping episode, Brooke, Chelsie, and Michelle delve into a spine-chilling true crime story that takes us back to the fateful New Year's Eve of 1989. They explore the case of Dr. John F. Boyle Jr., a former physician from Mansfield, Ohio, accused of the heinous murder of his wife, Noreen. With humorous interludes and light-hearted banter, the hosts guide us through the murky waters of deception, family betrayal, and legal battles, painting a picture of a man whose desperation led to murder.

Saturday Dec 21, 2024
Saturday Dec 21, 2024
In this gripping episode of Mom's Talk Murder, join Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie as they revisit the controversial and widely publicized case of Casey Anthony. Delve into the details of Casey's life, the mysterious disappearance and tragic death of her daughter, Caylee Anthony, and the tumultuous trial that followed.
The trio discusses the challenges faced during the investigation, including Casey's inconsistencies, the media frenzy, and the involvement of her family. They explore the trial's unexpected revelations, including allegations of molestation and the theory of an accidental drowning as a cover-up, which the defense presented against her father, George Anthony.
With engrossing debates and candid opinions, the hosts navigate the twists and turns of one of America's most infamous unsolved cases, questioning the judicial process and raising suspicions about the involvement of those closest to Caylee.
Join the discussion as the hosts offer their perspectives on this complex and emotionally charged case, sharing their thoughts on Casey Anthony's innocence, the family's dynamics, and the lingering mysteries that remain unsolved to this day.

Thursday Dec 12, 2024
Thursday Dec 12, 2024
Welcome to a chilling episode of Moms Talk Murder where hosts Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie delve into the eerie case of Michael J. Hoffman, infamously known as the Leaf Killer. This episode revisits Hoffman's unsettling obsession with trees, known as dendrophilia, which took a dark turn leading to shocking acts of violence.
The discussion opens with exciting updates about the podcast, including a new website aimed at enhancing listener experiences, complete with biographies, pictures, and future merchandise opportunities. As they prepare to dive into the case, laughter and anecdotes set the stage for revisiting Hoffman's story.
Listeners are transported back to 1980 in Warren, Ohio, where Hoffman’s life begins. Through trials and red flags, including arson and bizarre behavior surrounding his love for trees, his story spirals into alarming violence in November 2010. Explore the harrowing events that unfurled when Hoffman stalked a family, leading to devastating consequences and an unforgettable survivor, Sarah Maynard.
This episode also integrates humor and lighthearted digressions, offering insights into hunting traditions, community impacts, and the dark allure of true crime cases. Join us as we dissect Hoffman's motives, reflect on the aftermath, and ponder the perplexities of human behavior intertwined with nature.

Saturday Dec 07, 2024
Saturday Dec 07, 2024
This chilling episode of 'Mom's Talk Murder' delves into the terrifying world of Richard Cottingham, notoriously known as the Torso Killer. With hosts Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie, we journey back to the 1970s and 1980s, a time eerily marked by the rampant terror of serial killers. Focusing on Cottingham's heinous crimes, we explore his gruesome acts of murder and assault, alongside a discussion of the infamous Richard Cottingham – his psychological manipulations, crime patterns, and the shocking confessions that exposed his monstrous nature.
Amidst a backdrop of a notorious New York City underbelly, where sex work thrived, we examine the connections between Cottingham and other infamous figures of the era, including his eerie associations with Rodney Alcala. This episode also touches upon the daring lives of survivors who courageously testified against him, as well as the relentless pursuit of justice that finally led to his downfall.
Trigger warnings abound, as we recount the graphic and distressing details of Cottingham’s assaults and murders, always aiming to honor the victims and their stories. Join us for a deep dive into a twisted tale of power, control, and a chilling decade of darkness.

Thursday Nov 28, 2024
Thursday Nov 28, 2024
This episode of Moms Talk Murder dives deep into the chilling case of Rodney Alcala, infamously known as the "Dating Game Killer." The hosts continue their discussion on this deranged serial killer, exploring his twisted crimes, the media portrayal of his story, and the unnerving details of his trials. With intriguing insights and shocking revelations, this episode sheds light on the unsettling patterns of a murderer who evaded justice for far too long.
Listen as Brooke, Michelle, and Chelsie unpack the psychological aspects of Alcala's behavior, the system's failures, and the lasting impact on his victims. This episode delves into the complexities of his trial and why his case signifies a significant moment in the history of criminal justice. Tune in for an episode filled with suspense, critical analysis, and meaningful conversations about justice and closure.